Frequently Asked Questions

  • What makes the tortilla machine at Carniceria El Forastero different from other stores?

    The tortilla machine was imported directly from Mexico and is the only one of its kind in Montrose. It produces tortillas the traditional way in batches of 25–30 lbs multiple times daily. Fresh batches are made throughout the day and sold until they're gone.
  • How often is the daily dish of the day made at Carniceria El Forastero?

    One rotating dish is prepared fresh every morning by in-house cooks — examples include pork ribs with green chili, cabeza, and chile relleno. Nothing is reheated or held from the previous day. Recipes change based on what the cooks prepare that day, rooted in authentic Mexican regional tradition.
  • What's the difference between plain and marinated arrachera?

    Plain arrachera is fresh-cut skirt steak ready to season yourself. Marinated arrachera comes pre-seasoned with traditional Mexican spices. Both are cut to order from Cargill-sourced beef, and you can also get diezmillo in plain, marinated, or adobado styles with red chili.
  • Why does Montrose need fresh tortillas made daily?

    Colorado's dry high-desert air makes store-bought tortillas crack and dry out quickly. Fresh tortillas made on-site multiple times per day stay soft and pliable. The imported machine produces them the same way they're made in Mexico, meeting a daily need the community can't get elsewhere.
  • What weekend specials does Carniceria El Forastero offer?

    Weekends feature menudo, tamales, and birria — all made fresh on-site. These are traditional dishes prepared by experienced cooks using authentic recipes. Weekend specials complement the daily rotating dish and expand the menu beyond weekday offerings.
  • How are carnitas made at Carniceria El Forastero?

    Carnitas are slow-cooked traditionally by experienced in-house cooks — not oven-roasted or rushed. The owner specifically calls them out as one of the store's signature items. They're made fresh daily and available in larger quantities on weekends for family gatherings and events.
  • What authentic grocery products does Carniceria El Forastero carry?

    The store stocks imported products from Mexico, El Salvador, Nicaragua, Colombia, and Venezuela. This includes ingredients and specialty items unavailable at standard grocery stores. The selection serves the growing Latin American community in Montrose with products that taste like home.
  • Can you get custom butcher cuts the same day in Montrose?

    Yes — meats are cut to order while you wait, not pre-packaged. The spacious store layout with shopping cart access makes it comfortable to browse and request specific cuts. All beef and pork are sourced fresh from Cargill and cut to your exact specification.
  • What's baked fresh daily at the Mexican bakery?

    Conchas, bolillos, and seasonal pan dulce varieties are baked in-house every morning. Nothing is thawed from frozen or sourced from a distributor. The in-house bakery operation is uncommon for a carnicería and makes this a full-service Latin market under one roof.
  • What tacos are available every day at Carniceria El Forastero?

    Tacos al asada and al pastor are prepared daily using fresh-cut meats and handmade tortillas made on-site. Weekly and weekend specials add variety beyond the everyday options. Everything is scratch-made — no frozen ingredients or shortcuts — and ready for takeout.
  • Why did Carniceria El Forastero open in Montrose?

    The owner's husband ran a taco truck and struggled to source affordable quality meat locally, so he opened his own carnicería in March. What started as a practical solution became a community resource serving the Uncompahgre Valley's growing Latin American population.
  • How is Carniceria El Forastero different from other Mexican markets in Montrose?

    It's the only store with a tortilla machine imported from Mexico, in-house bakery, rotating daily prepared dishes, and full butcher service under one roof. The spacious layout with shopping carts makes it easier to navigate than smaller competing carnicerías, and everything is made fresh daily on-site.